Battle: Jean Timmins made her own checks before her bank let the sums be paid
Why should it often take the intervention of the press to get financial justice for consumers? It’s a question I regularly ask myself – although I can’t deny I thoroughly enjoy the moment whenever a mighty financial services company caves in, usually for fear of getting a pasting in the personal finance pages of The Mail on Sunday. It makes me feel good and vindicates my profession. For example, over the years I’ve managed to get many insurance giants to review claims they had originally rejected and pay out huge sums as a result.
Invariably, the policies were bought to provide financial protection at a time when it is most needed – when a household is struck by long-term illness or a life- threatening health condition. To have a claim rejected against such a scary backdrop can be deeply unsettling, especially when the reason given is a spurious one based on disputed medical evidence or the nondisclosure of a medical issue many moons ago.
Thankfully, our interventions have often righted these wrongs.
It has happened again in recent days, albeit in a different area of the financial services industry. Recently, I’ve been looking at some of the scams that have caught out a number of readers. Scams committed by fraudsters which have resulted in devastating financial losses for those targeted. They came to my attention because of an article I wrote last month on investment cloning – in which a fraudster copies the details of a legitimate financial services firm and then persuades investors to make investments through the fraudulent website. The money invested is never seen again.
Jean Timmins, a lovely 72-year-old retired secondary school teacher from Wolverhampton, was one of those who contacted me – egged on by her neighbour Phil Haden, a financial adviser whom I have known for a while. Since the end of last year, she had been battling with her bank (Santander) over two payments she made to scammers totalling £30,300.
Only our intervention got her the money back. Why? Let’s go back to the start. Last September, like many people, Jean was looking for a better return on her cash savings. National Savings & Investments, her savings port of call, had just slashed its rates, so she started to hunt on the internet for better alternatives.
She came across a company called Redmaine Cooper Price offering what looked like attractive bonds. Everything seemed normal – the company had a London address and an authorisation number from the City regulator. She completed a form online and then received a call from someone called John Watts who said that there was a bond available (UK Treasury 6 per cent) that might interest her.
‘He was very professional,’ says Jean. ‘He emailed details about the bond, including when interest would be paid [bi-annually] and the date the bond matured [December 2028]. Given it was a Government bond, I couldn’t see how it could go wrong. In order to invest, he said I would have to send copies of my passport photo identification, which I duly did.’
Emails from Watts referred to his 15 years of experience ‘working in UK bond markets’. They also quoted a regulator’s authorisation number and referred her to the regulator’s list of approved companies. These details appeared to confirm that RCP was an authorised company.
Maybe it was the next bit that should have raised a few alarms in Jean’s mind. ‘He said there may be a problem with my bank Santander releasing the money,’ she recollects. ‘He said Santander would prefer me to buy its own products – and he advised me, if questioned by the bank, to say the money I was investing was to buy goods, not bonds.’
She duly invested £10,300 and, although challenged by Santander, the payment (to RGS Clearing Limited) went through. Susan Clarke, in administration at Redmaine Cooper Price, confirmed receipt of the money and gave Jean details of how she could track her investment online.
Later the same month (October), John Watts phoned again to say he had another bond that might interest her – this time with Lloyds, a company he said was safe as the bank was still part Government owned. It was a lie – the Government divested its stake in Lloyds nearly four years ago. After being told the bond had a coupon of 9.625 per cent and paid annual interest until April 2023, Jean was hooked and sold a cash Isa so that she could invest £20,000 in the bond. Again, Santander queried the transfer, but allowed the payment through.
It was in December, when she could no longer log in to her account, that she became suspicious. She rang the regulator’s helpline and was advised to contact her bank. Unbeknown to Jean, only weeks earlier, the Financial Conduct Authority had issued a warning about Redmaine Cooper Price, stating it had cloned the details of a French-based company called RCP, authorised to sell financial products in the UK.
In other words, John Watts, Susan Clarke and Chris Moore (allegedly Redmaine Cooper Price’s compliance officer) were scammers. Last month, after investigating the scam, Santander wrote to Jean, telling her that it would not be reimbursing her losses. It had assessed her case against the voluntary ‘contingent reimbursement model’ code for authorised push payment scams – and had concluded she had not taken the care ‘that was expected’. Push payments are where people are persuaded to make real-time payments to fraudsters.
She was furious. ‘What more could I have done?’ she asks. ‘I had phoned the FCA to check the company’s authorisation. I had phoned the company (RCP), only to be told everyone was working from home because of Covid. And I assumed Santander had done its own checking when querying the two payments.’
Not happy, she said she would take her complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
Earlier this month, she mentioned the scam in passing to a neighbour – Phil Haden, a chartered financial planner with Prosperity Wealth. Having exchanged a few emails over the years, he asked me to take a look. I promptly contacted Santander.
Help: Police are increasingly likely to come knocking at your door if they think you are being scammed online
After a couple of days, it responded to say that it was overturning its original decision to decline Jean’s claim. It said no blame could be attributed to her.
It said: ‘Having reviewed Mrs Timmins’ claim, we will be refunding £30,300 to her under the CRM code’s ‘no blame’ scenario. Both of Mrs Timmins’ payments were stopped by our fraud prevention systems while we had conversations with her, warning her to perform further checks on Redmaine Cooper Price, including confirming its legitimacy with the FCA.
‘Mrs Timmins has confirmed that she called the FCA before making the first payment, and we believe in this instance that she reasonably felt she had carried out suitable checks before making the transfer.’
Upon hearing the news, Jean’s response was joyous. In an email to me a few days ago, she said: ‘I was totally overwhelmed when, yesterday evening, I heard Santander would be refunding the whole of the monies to me. I cannot thank you enough for doing this and I am very grateful. ‘I also hope that in highlighting my case, you may help unsuspecting people avoid falling victim to these disgusting scams.’
So, a great result in the end. But it begs the question: how many Jeans are out there who have been victims of scams and have been left high and dry by their bank? Too many, I fear. The quicker the banks are required to give better protection to the likes of Jean, the better.
THIS IS MONEY PODCAST
- What happens next to the property market and house prices?
- The UK has dodged a double-dip recession, so what next?
- Will you confess your investing mistakes?
- Should the GameStop frenzy be stopped to protect investors?
- Should people cash in bitcoin profits or wait for the moon?
- Is this the answer to pension freedom without the pain?
- Are investors right to buy British for better times after lockdown?
- The astonishing year that was 2020… and Christmas taste test
- Is buy now, pay later bad news or savvy spending?
- Would a ‘wealth tax’ work in Britain?
- Is there still time for investors to go bargain hunting?
- Is Britain ready for electric cars? Driving, charging and buying…
- Will the vaccine rally and value investing revival continue?
- How bad will Lockdown 2 be for the UK economy?
- Is this the end of ‘free’ banking or can it survive?
- Has the V-shaped recovery turned into a double-dip?
- Should British investors worry about the US election?
- Is Boris’s 95% mortgage idea a bad move?
- Can we keep our lockdown savings habit?
- Will the Winter Economy Plan save jobs?
- How to make an offer in a seller’s market and avoid overpaying
- Could you fall victim to lockdown fraud? How to fight back
- What’s behind the UK property and US shares lockdown mini-booms?
- Do you know how your pension is invested?
- Online supermarket battle intensifies with M&S and Ocado tie-up
- Is the coronavirus recession better or worse than it looks?
- Can you make a profit and get your money to do some good?
- Are negative interest rates off the table and what next for gold?
- Has the pain in Spain killed off summer holidays this year?
- How to start investing and grow your wealth
- Will the Government tinker with capital gains tax?
- Will a stamp duty cut and Rishi’s rescue plan be enough?
- The self-employed excluded from the coronavirus rescue
- Has lockdown left you with more to save or struggling?
- Are banks triggering a mortgage credit crunch?
- The rise of the lockdown investor – and tips to get started
- Are electric bikes and scooters the future of getting about?
- Are we all going on a summer holiday?
- Could your savings rate turn negative?
- How many state pensions were underpaid? With Steve Webb
- Santander’s 123 chop and how do we pay for the crash?
- Is the Fomo rally the read deal, or will shares dive again?
- Is investing instead of saving worth the risk?
- How bad will recession be – and what will recovery look like?
- Staying social and bright ideas on the ‘good news episode’
- Is furloughing workers the best way to save jobs?
- Will the coronavirus lockdown sink house prices?
- Will helicopter money be the antidote to the coronavirus crisis?
- The Budget, the base rate cut and the stock market crash
- Does Nationwide’s savings lottery show there’s life in the cash Isa?
- Bull markets don’t die of old age, but do they die of coronavirus?
- How do you make comedy pay the bills? Shappi Khorsandi on Making the…
- As NS&I and Marcus cut rates, what’s the point of saving?
- Will the new Chancellor give pension tax relief the chop?
- Are you ready for an electric car? And how to buy at 40% off
- How to fund a life of adventure: Alastair Humphreys
- What does Brexit mean for your finances and rights?
- Are tax returns too taxing – and should you do one?
- Has Santander killed off current accounts with benefits?
- Making the Money Work: Olympic boxer Anthony Ogogo
- Does the watchdog have a plan to finally help savers?
- Making the Money Work: Solo Atlantic rower Kiko Matthews
- The biggest stories of 2019: From Woodford to the wealth gap
- Does the Boris bounce have legs?
- Are the rich really getting richer and poor poorer?
- It could be you! What would you spend a lottery win on?
- Who will win the election battle for the future of our finances?
- How does Labour plan to raise taxes and spend?
- Would you buy an electric car yet – and which are best?
- How much should you try to burglar-proof your home?
- Does loyalty pay? Nationwide, Tesco and where we are loyal
- Will investors benefit from Woodford being axed and what next?
- Does buying a property at auction really get you a good deal?
- Crunch time for Brexit, but should you protect or try to profit?
- How much do you need to save into a pension?
- Is a tough property market the best time to buy a home?
- Should investors and buy-to-letters pay more tax on profits?
- Savings rate cuts, buy-to-let vs right to buy and a bit of Brexit
- Do those born in the 80s really face a state pension age of 75?
- Can consumer power help the planet? Look after your back yard
- Is there a recession looming and what next for interest rates?
- Tricks ruthless scammers use to steal your pension revealed
- Is IR35 a tax trap for the self-employed or making people play fair?
- What Boris as Prime Minister means for your money
Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click on them we may earn a small commission. That helps us fund This Is Money, and keep it free to use. We do not write articles to promote products. We do not allow any commercial relationship to affect our editorial independence.